14 Rare Toys From the 90s That Could Make You Rich in 2025

That box of old toys in your attic? It might be worth more than you think. As nostalgia continues to drive collector demand, certain 90s toys are now selling for thousands—especially if they’re in good condition or still sealed. These aren’t just childhood memories anymore. They’re appreciating assets hiding in plain sight.

1. Tamagotchi (First Generation)

The original Tamagotchis from 1996 are now collectible gold—especially the Japan-only models. A sealed first-gen version can fetch $500 to $1,000 depending on color and condition. Limited editions push even higher.

2. Pokémon Cards (1st Edition Base Set)

This one’s no secret anymore, but it’s still climbing. First Edition holographic cards like Charizard, Blastoise, and Venusaur have sold for tens—sometimes hundreds—of thousands. Even common 1st Edition cards in mint condition are worth grading.

3. Beanie Babies (The Real Rare Ones)

Most Beanie Babies are worthless. But a few—like Princess Diana, Peanut the Royal Blue Elephant, and the original Valentino—are still drawing serious offers if they’re authenticated and have tag errors.

4. Nintendo 64 (Factory Sealed Console)

An unopened Nintendo 64 box from the late 90s is worth serious money. Factory-sealed systems can go for $1,000–$3,000, with certain bundle editions (like Donkey Kong 64) pulling even more at auction.

5. Polly Pocket (Bluebird Versions)

The original Polly Pockets made by Bluebird Toys before Mattel bought the brand are highly sought after. Complete sets in good condition can sell for $500+, and rare compacts can climb into the thousands.

6. Talkboy (from Home Alone 2)

Made famous by Kevin McCallister, the Talkboy is a cult favorite. Working versions can sell for $200–$500, but sealed in-box versions? Those now cross the $1,000 mark regularly with collectors.

7. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (1990s Action Figures)

The original TMNT action figures from Playmates have held their value well—especially if unopened. Rare variants like the Scratch figure or Toon Turtles can easily hit four figures in mint condition.

8. Mighty Max (Complete Playsets)

Often overlooked, Mighty Max sets were the edgier cousin to Polly Pocket. Sealed or complete vintage playsets—especially the Doom Zones—are selling for $200 to $800 depending on rarity and condition.

9. Street Sharks (Hand-Shark Figures)

These over-the-top action figures now have a cult following. Especially valuable are the hand puppet versions and rarer characters like Moby Lick. Sealed figures can go for $300 to $700 easily.

10. Game Boy Color (Special Editions)

Standard units are collectible, but the special editions—like Pokémon Yellow or the Atomic Purple version—command a premium. Sealed or boxed consoles can sell for $500–$2,000 depending on region and rarity.

11. Bop It (First Gen, in Box)

The original 1996 Bop It isn’t just fun nostalgia—it’s valuable. A first-edition, sealed version can sell for $250–$600. Limited color runs and error packaging push even higher among collectors.

12. McDonald’s Happy Meal Toys (Full Sets)

Some Happy Meal toys from the 90s—especially full sets from franchises like Mulan, Batman, or Space Jam—are now collectibles. Factory-sealed sets can sell for $100–$500 depending on demand.

13. G.I. Joe Extreme (Short-Run Series)

While the classic 80s G.I. Joes get most of the attention, the short-lived 90s “Extreme” line has quietly gained value. Mint figures or complete sets are climbing fast, often reaching $200–$800 per item.

14. LEGO Sets (Retired 90s Kits)

LEGO collectors are serious. Retired sets from the 90s—especially space themes, early Star Wars kits, or pirate ships—can sell for thousands. Even used sets with original boxes are in high demand.

The Bottom Line

If you grew up in the 90s, your childhood toys might be worth more than you think. Sealed packaging, good condition, and rare editions are what drive value. With nostalgia peaking and collectors paying top dollar, now might be the perfect time to dig through those old bins—or start collecting intentionally.