Old tools aren’t just for the shed anymore. Collectors are paying big money for certain vintage hand tools—especially ones that are rare, well-preserved, or tied to iconic manufacturers. What used to sit forgotten in garages and barns is now popping up at auctions and antique shows for thousands. Here are nine tools that could turn your toolbox into a goldmine.
1. Stanley No. 1 Bench Plane
This tiny hand plane is one of the most sought-after tools in the world of collectors. Produced by Stanley in the late 1800s, it’s rare, compact, and surprisingly valuable. Clean examples often fetch $1,500–$3,000, and pristine ones have gone even higher.
2. Goodell-Pratt Hand Drills
Before power drills took over, Goodell-Pratt was one of the top names in precision hand tools. Their early eggbeater-style drills—especially with wooden handles and original bits—can bring in $300–$800 depending on condition.
3. Disston Back Saws (Pre-1900)
Disston was the gold standard for American saws in the 1800s. Back saws with ornate medallions, carved handles, and original etching can command hundreds at auction—sometimes over $1,000 if they’re early and clean.
4. Stanley No. 444 Dovetail Plane
This specialized plane was only made for a few years, and even then, not in high quantities. It’s a collector’s dream due to its unique function and scarcity. Complete sets in the original box have sold for $2,000–$4,000 at auction.
5. Millers Falls Miter Boxes
Millers Falls made some of the most precise miter boxes of the early 20th century. Heavy-duty cast-iron versions with their original saws intact can bring in $500–$1,200 depending on rarity and size.
6. Winchester-Branded Tools
Yes, that Winchester—the firearms company—briefly made tools in the 1920s. Because of the crossover appeal to both tool and gun collectors, these items are now worth a lot. A clean Winchester hand plane or screwdriver can bring $300–$800, or more in rare cases.
7. Norris Infill Planes (Made in England)
These British-made planes are heavy, precise, and beautifully built. Collectors love them for their craftsmanship and scarcity. Certain models, especially pre-WWII versions with original irons, regularly sell for $1,500–$3,500.
8. Atkins Perfection Saws
Often overshadowed by Disston, Atkins made high-end saws with decorative etching and premium materials. The “Perfection” line is especially collectible. A well-preserved example can sell for $400–$1,000, depending on the handle and blade detail.
9. Early Brass Calipers or Rules
Pre-1900 measuring tools, especially those made of brass or ivory, are highly collectible. Folding rules from makers like Stanley or Lufkin with inlaid joints and crisp markings can sell for $300–$700 or more if they’re intact and rare.
The Bottom Line
If you’ve inherited a box of old tools—or just love hunting at flea markets—it might be worth a closer look. Certain vintage tools aren’t just functional—they’re historical artifacts. And as collectors continue to hunt for rare finds, prices are only going up. A little rust might be hiding a big return.
Alexander Clark is a financial writer with a knack for breaking down complex market trends and economic shifts. As a contributor to The Daily Overview, he offers readers clear, insightful analysis on everything from market movements to personal finance strategies. With a keen eye for detail and a passion for keeping up with the fast-paced world of finance, Alexander strives to make financial news accessible and engaging for everyone.
