Infinity Auto Insurance must refund over $46 million to Florida drivers

Image by Freepik

Florida’s insurance regulator says Infinity Auto Insurance Company will return more than $46 million in excess profits to its policyholders. The Office of Insurance Regulation announced the result on November 2, 2026, and the profits cover calendar and accident years 2023, 2024 and 2025.

The refunds are described as automatic, so no application form appears in the announcement or in the order behind it. What remains open is smaller but practical: who is on the list, how the money arrives, and what happens when a check is returned. The facts below come from the regulator’s release, the signed order and Florida’s excess profit statute.

What the regulator announced and what the order requires

In its November 2 release, the Office says Commissioner Mike Yaworsky secured over $46 million in excess profits that will be returned to policyholders, and that Infinity Auto Insurance Company will refund the profits to consumers within 60 days. The release says nothing about an exact payment date.

The Office’s final order, Case 403430-26-FO, gives the precise figure of $46,246,666 for 2023, 2024 and 2025, valued at March 31, 2026. It directs Infinity to provide refunds or policy renewal credits within sixty days of the order, and it carries a stamp showing it was filed on October 22, 2026. The order records that Infinity waived its hearing on October 12. The release and the order count the 60 days differently, so no end date is calculated here.


Inside the guide: A refund that arrives by mail from an insurer leaves a household with a small record-keeping job: noting whether a check came, whether it was cashed, and which state office to search if it is returned. The Settlement & Refund Recovery System includes a claim log and payment tracker plus a 5-tab Excel tracker pre-filled with all 51 state unclaimed-property offices for that purpose.

The excess profit test behind the order

Florida’s Section 627.066 requires each private passenger auto insurer group to file data every year before July 1. An excessive profit exists when underwriting gains for the three most recent calendar-accident years combined exceed the anticipated underwriting profit plus 5 percent of earned premiums for those years. The order says Infinity filed its data on June 30, 2026.

Once excess profit is found, the statute says a refund is required unless the insurer shows that paying would leave a member financially impaired or insolvent. The money can be returned as a cash refund or as a credit toward future insurance purchases, so the form of payment is set by the statute and the order rather than chosen by the policyholder.

The Office adds that it is reminding other auto insurers of the same duty. Yaworsky said other companies are approaching the statutory threshold and that more refund announcements are expected.

Who is in line, and what the release leaves open

The release refers to policyholders and Florida consumers without listing policy types, counties or a count of people. The statute supplies the general rule: amounts are distributed pro rata, based on earned premiums in the final year of the review period, to voluntary private passenger auto policyholders of record on December 31 of that final year. For this order, the review period ends with 2025, which points to policyholders on record at the end of 2025, though the release does not restate that date for Infinity.

Several facts are not published. The release gives no per-driver amount, no number of recipients and no split between checks and renewal credits. The statute says cash refunds are due within 60 days of the final order, while credits go on renewal notices sent more than 60 days after it.

A labeled example of pro rata arithmetic

Pro rata by earned premium means a larger premium base earns a larger share. The figures below are hypothetical and are not Infinity’s numbers. If a refund pool were $1,000 and the earned premiums of all eligible policies totaled $10,000, each premium dollar would map to 10 cents. A policy with $1,500 of earned premium would then receive $150.

The real result depends on Infinity’s total earned premium for the final year, which the release does not state, so a check cannot be estimated from the $46,246,666 total alone.

Returned checks and the Florida unclaimed property path

The release and the order both say Infinity will attempt to locate policyholders whose refund checks are returned. If a policyholder is not reached, the insurer must report and process the unclaimed profit funds as unclaimed or abandoned property under Chapter 717 of the Florida Statutes. The order also requires Infinity to certify to the Office that refunds were made and that the search effort was completed.

Money handled that way is held by the Florida Department of Financial Services. Its Claim Your Cash Florida site, which the older fltreasurehunt.gov address redirects to, offers a property search and a claim status tool. The site says there is never a fee to search for or claim cash, that there is no deadline to claim, and that the Department will not contact anyone by text about a claim. The page does not list a phone number.

The mistakes that cost money or time

The most common error is treating an automatic refund like a claim that needs a fee. Because the money comes from the insurer or from the state’s own property program, any third party asking for a payment to release it conflicts with the state’s statement that searching and claiming is free.

A second error is losing track of mail. A check can be sent to the address Infinity holds, and a returned check sets the unclaimed property process in motion. The Office’s main line, (850) 413-3140, is listed on the release, and the release lists no separate consumer helpline. Questions about a specific refund belong with Infinity.

The third error is assuming an amount. The statute’s pro rata rule means two drivers with different premiums may receive different sums, and a renewal credit is not a check. Keeping the envelope, the date it arrived and the name on the check makes any later search or correction simpler.


Tracking an insurer refund check from mailbox to unclaimed property

The Florida order on Infinity Auto Insurance leaves a gap between a refund being ordered and a household knowing whether a check arrived, was cashed or came back undeliverable. When a check is returned, the funds can move into Florida unclaimed property, which is a separate record trail from the insurer’s own.

The Settlement & Refund Recovery System contains a claim log and payment tracker, a 5-tab Excel tracker pre-filled with all 51 state unclaimed-property offices, and the source vault of 12 official places money sits.

Look up the state unclaimed-property office list and log each refund check in The Settlement & Refund Recovery System.

This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed for accuracy against the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation release and final order, Section 627.066 of the Florida Statutes and the Claim Your Cash Florida site read in November 2026.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *