Humana is cutting Medicare Advantage plans for 600,000 members

T Leish/Pexels

About 600,000 people in Humana Medicare Advantage plans are learning this month that the plan they are in will not exist next year. The company told investors in July that its targeted 2027 plan exits would affect roughly that many members, and the letters carrying the news are dated October 2 under a federal rule that fixes the date every year.

The timing is deliberate. Those notices are required to land before Medicare’s annual Open Enrollment Period opens on October 15, which gives affected members a defined window to pick something else before coverage ends on December 31. Members who do nothing are not left without coverage, but they are left with a set of consequences most of them have never had to think about.

Why the letters are dated October 2

The date is not Humana’s choice. Federal regulation at 42 CFR 422.2267 requires a Medicare Advantage organization to send a non-renewal notice at least 90 calendar days before the non-renewal takes effect, and it specifies that for contracts ending on December 31 the notice must be dated October 2. The fixed date keeps one downstream protection — the right to buy a Medigap policy without medical underwriting — consistent nationally rather than varying with how quickly each insurer mailed. Enrollees in special needs plans are the exception.

The notice has to say when coverage ends, what the enrollment options are, and what happens to someone who takes no action. It is a different document from the Annual Notice of Change, which goes to members whose plan is continuing but changing. A household can receive both in the same stretch of October, and the two call for different responses.


What the non-renewal letter does not do: The October 2 notice names the date the plan ends and the windows for acting, but it does not compare the alternatives available in that county on cost, prescriptions and doctors — the comparison that decides which replacement plan is actually cheaper over a full year. The cost calculator spreadsheet that weighs plans on cost, drugs and doctors does that side-by-side work in The 2027 Medicare Open Enrollment Decision Kit.

Two windows, not one

The first window is the one everyone on Medicare shares. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services sets Open Enrollment from October 15 through December 7, and during it a beneficiary can compare current costs, benefits, drug coverage and provider networks against the plans offered for 2027 and switch. Coverage chosen in that window starts January 1.

The second window belongs specifically to people whose plan is not being renewed. Medicare’s special enrollment rules give them a separate period running from December 8 through the last day of February. That is a genuine safety net for anyone who misses December 7, but it is not equivalent to acting on time: a choice made in January or February leaves a gap at the start of the year in which the old plan has ended and the new one has not begun.

A contract that Medicare itself terminates carries different dates again, and a mutual termination uses another set. The letter a member receives says which situation applies.

The Medigap right that comes with an involuntary exit

The more valuable protection in this situation is easy to miss, because it only exists for people whose plan left them rather than the other way around. Under federal law, a beneficiary whose Medicare Advantage plan stops serving their area and who moves to Original Medicare has a guaranteed-issue right to buy certain Medigap policies. Medicare’s own guide to Medigap sets out what that means in practice: during the protected period an insurer cannot refuse to sell a policy, cannot charge more because of health history, and cannot impose a waiting period for a pre-existing condition.

For an involuntary termination, that protected period begins when the member receives the termination notice and continues until 63 days after the Medicare Advantage coverage ends. Some states add further protections on top. The practical point is that the window closes, and a person in poor health who waits past it can find that the same Medigap policy is either priced out of reach or unavailable.

What is driving the exits

Humana described the cuts to investors as a profitability decision rather than a retreat. On the company’s second-quarter earnings call on July 29, chief financial officer Celeste Mellet said the company would “remove or cut off the lower tail of profitability and returns” instead of trimming benefits evenly across its portfolio, in order to protect the benefits attached to its stronger plans. Most of the discontinued plans carry ratings of 3.5 stars or lower for the 2027 bonus year, though Mellet said star ratings were not the primary driver.

Humana expects to keep a share of the affected members by moving them into its other plans in the same markets, having retained slightly more than 40% of those hit by its 2025 exits. Members are not moved automatically, though — retention happens only when someone actively enrolls in another Humana plan during the enrollment window.

The mistake that costs the most

The expensive error here is treating the letter as information rather than a deadline. Doing nothing does not mean keeping the current plan, because the current plan will not exist. A member who takes no action by December 31 falls back to Original Medicare, which has no out-of-pocket maximum of its own, no built-in prescription drug coverage, and — once the 63-day guaranteed-issue window has run out — no guaranteed path into a Medigap policy to cover the gaps.

The second mistake is comparing on premium alone. A replacement plan can advertise a lower monthly price and still cost more across a year if it drops a regularly used prescription from its formulary, moves a specialist out of network, or carries a higher out-of-pocket limit. Checking each prescription, each pharmacy and each regular doctor against a specific plan’s 2027 documents is the work that separates a good switch from an expensive one.

Humana has not published which counties and which plans are affected, so the letter itself is the only reliable notice an individual member will get. Anyone on Medicare who has not seen their October mail yet has reason to open it carefully. Plan-specific questions can go to 1-800-MEDICARE, and the Medicare Plan Finder lists what is available in a given ZIP code for 2027.


Turning a non-renewal letter into a decision

A plan ending on December 31 converts an October letter into two dated choices: a replacement plan by December 7, or a move to Original Medicare with a Medigap policy bought inside the 63-day guaranteed-issue window. Both run on the member’s own prescriptions, pharmacies and doctors, and neither the non-renewal notice nor the plan’s marketing assembles that comparison for them.

The 2027 Medicare Open Enrollment Decision Kit pairs a prescription-by-plan comparison with a provider call script and the Open Enrollment calendar, along with the Medigap guaranteed-issue rules for a plan that leaves and a script for the call that follows.

Compare the 2027 options in The 2027 Medicare Open Enrollment Decision Kit.

This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed for accuracy against official government sources.